Or did they?
When Natasha Asghar isn't a TV presenter, anchor and a model she is the Conservative Candidate for Torfaen in the Welsh General Election.
I had a leaflet through the door, not very showy to be fair, saying that 'We called to see you today...'.
Although I was in work, my wife and kids were in all day. My three year old son has x-men like powers at hearing the front door (with the speed of a puma to match when running to the door upon knock), yet none of them heard the door go. My wife, as apolitical as they come, actually said she wanted to give the Tories a piece of her mind over the tax credit changes that will massively effect us. Shame they only pretend they knock the door then...
At least they have used local printers. The independent candidate, Councillor Elizabeth Haynes, makes alot of how she will support local business and 'local jobs for local people'. Noble aims, apart from any detail about how she will actually do that, but slightly let down by the fact she has used a printers in London.
I am sure there was a Torfaen printers crying out to do 20,000 leaflets for someone.
Monday, 18 April 2011
Sunday, 17 April 2011
Changing my mind on the ballot paper
The AV ballot paper was the first whereby I still was unsure upon putting a crossing in one or the other.
I have steadfastly maintained a 'if you want PR, Vote No'. But given that I fail to see how the two main Westminster parties will ever act like Turkey's voting for christmas over PR, I changed my mind and voted yes.
I think people will vote no anyway, although a yes vote won by the celtic nations would be a good, even if a little mischievous. The more we can make the English realise the UK is a bum deal, the better.
I have steadfastly maintained a 'if you want PR, Vote No'. But given that I fail to see how the two main Westminster parties will ever act like Turkey's voting for christmas over PR, I changed my mind and voted yes.
I think people will vote no anyway, although a yes vote won by the celtic nations would be a good, even if a little mischievous. The more we can make the English realise the UK is a bum deal, the better.
Friday, 15 April 2011
The 100% Positive Canvass
It strikes me that some in the political class who don't go through the business of trying to win elections claim a sense of one up man ship. I have respect for anyone willing to face the public in ultimately is a test of popularity of personality, deeds and popularity.
This attitude is found in some taking the piss out of political people who all talk about canvassing in positive terms. 'Great response in town X', of course the election results cannot possibly bear out that (not everyone will get the positive result).
However, I actually believe there are decent reasons for this. Firstly, despite what some will tell you, people are generally welcoming of political campaigners. Granted, you get the same old people saying 'you only see them around election time/I aint voting for none of you', but given they have confirmed they will never vote you can hardly expect political campaigners to prioritise those people.
Secondly, in my view political campaigners are interested in one thing on the door during an election campaign - useful data. You can try to pick up a case and promise to look into it, but with a few weeks until election day, not many cases can be solved in that time. You will record confirmed support for other parties, but identifying your support (confirmed and potential) is ultimately the point of things. This feeds into the 'positive response' comments - you remember the things that ultimately are useful to your goal.
Thirdly, many candidates are still trying to motivate volunteers to help them for free. You wouldn't be human if you hesitated in giving up your time unless you felt it was helping in the wider goal. If your candidate is telling you it is negative and there is no support...
Fourthly, most voters are undecided - yet they decide elections. Political people, ones who will only vote one way no matter what, are a small section of the electorate. Many are undecided, many haven't given it's a moments thought, some don't even know there are elections on. These people's responses range from the 'thanks, will now shut the door and see if I want to vote' to 'thanks, I will now vote for you'. Often canvassing is the only way to reach these voters.
And lastly, I am not wet enough to believe that many people are too polite to do anything but nod, make some non committal "not sure yet", take a leaflet and not really think that much about it.
If you think about it, I have no doubt that many people do encounter a positive response on the door.
This attitude is found in some taking the piss out of political people who all talk about canvassing in positive terms. 'Great response in town X', of course the election results cannot possibly bear out that (not everyone will get the positive result).
However, I actually believe there are decent reasons for this. Firstly, despite what some will tell you, people are generally welcoming of political campaigners. Granted, you get the same old people saying 'you only see them around election time/I aint voting for none of you', but given they have confirmed they will never vote you can hardly expect political campaigners to prioritise those people.
Secondly, in my view political campaigners are interested in one thing on the door during an election campaign - useful data. You can try to pick up a case and promise to look into it, but with a few weeks until election day, not many cases can be solved in that time. You will record confirmed support for other parties, but identifying your support (confirmed and potential) is ultimately the point of things. This feeds into the 'positive response' comments - you remember the things that ultimately are useful to your goal.
Thirdly, many candidates are still trying to motivate volunteers to help them for free. You wouldn't be human if you hesitated in giving up your time unless you felt it was helping in the wider goal. If your candidate is telling you it is negative and there is no support...
Fourthly, most voters are undecided - yet they decide elections. Political people, ones who will only vote one way no matter what, are a small section of the electorate. Many are undecided, many haven't given it's a moments thought, some don't even know there are elections on. These people's responses range from the 'thanks, will now shut the door and see if I want to vote' to 'thanks, I will now vote for you'. Often canvassing is the only way to reach these voters.
And lastly, I am not wet enough to believe that many people are too polite to do anything but nod, make some non committal "not sure yet", take a leaflet and not really think that much about it.
If you think about it, I have no doubt that many people do encounter a positive response on the door.
Thursday, 14 April 2011
A Question...
When out delivering the postal vote letters in Panteg, I saw a lady who was knocking on doors. I was intrigued, a Labour member around my age in Torfaen?
Alas no, it was a (very nice) young lady who was chasing people up regarding their census forms.
It made me think why something as rather outdated as the Census, but voting isn't?
I wrote about this subject here.
Alas no, it was a (very nice) young lady who was chasing people up regarding their census forms.
It made me think why something as rather outdated as the Census, but voting isn't?
I wrote about this subject here.
Tuesday, 12 April 2011
Positive vs. Negative
I always believe that if you are going to criticise something, you have to have an alternative. It is not enough, particularly when we are talking about policy, to merely slate what everyone else is doing.
Politics is a funny old game, one which sometimes can genuinely cut in the public mindset, but often almost run in a parallel world of political speak.
Plaid Cymru's manifesto can be read here.
You would expect me to praise it, but I want to offer more than that, I want to challenge others to come up with better ideas. It is a gauntlet we have thrown down to Labour - one which they cannot ignore. Wales has alot of deep rooted problems, more deep rooted than the current economic problems we are all feeling. Not every idea brought forward will make it into Government policy and not every idea might work as intended (as an aside, I think politicians are often scared stiff of admitting that radical social change through policy has to be slightly trial and error. Clearly there must always be scope to react to unattended reactions to a certain policy.)
However, I am confident and excited that Plaid are the ones with ideas, the ones willing to want to change things. Ultimately this election narrative is about a positive vote for Wales or a negative 'sending a message to London' (which even if you believe, does not even begin to solve any of Wales' problems or improve it).
Labour's headline so far has been "Vote Labour to send a Message to David Cameron and Nick Clegg". Essentially the political equivalent of putting a dog turd through their letterbox or ordering a pizza to be delivered to their house. Messaged delivered, now what?
I am not going to go OTT, I am talking about the narrative, clearly Labour believe (and polls show some support) for the UK focus of these Welsh elections. It is a slow process, but each Assembly election will slowly move away from that focus.
But all we can do is try to speak to as many voters as we can and do so with positive ideas about what we can change, not sending a message to London to a Government we cannot.
Gauntlet thrown down - positive vs negative.
Politics is a funny old game, one which sometimes can genuinely cut in the public mindset, but often almost run in a parallel world of political speak.
Plaid Cymru's manifesto can be read here.
You would expect me to praise it, but I want to offer more than that, I want to challenge others to come up with better ideas. It is a gauntlet we have thrown down to Labour - one which they cannot ignore. Wales has alot of deep rooted problems, more deep rooted than the current economic problems we are all feeling. Not every idea brought forward will make it into Government policy and not every idea might work as intended (as an aside, I think politicians are often scared stiff of admitting that radical social change through policy has to be slightly trial and error. Clearly there must always be scope to react to unattended reactions to a certain policy.)
However, I am confident and excited that Plaid are the ones with ideas, the ones willing to want to change things. Ultimately this election narrative is about a positive vote for Wales or a negative 'sending a message to London' (which even if you believe, does not even begin to solve any of Wales' problems or improve it).
Labour's headline so far has been "Vote Labour to send a Message to David Cameron and Nick Clegg". Essentially the political equivalent of putting a dog turd through their letterbox or ordering a pizza to be delivered to their house. Messaged delivered, now what?
I am not going to go OTT, I am talking about the narrative, clearly Labour believe (and polls show some support) for the UK focus of these Welsh elections. It is a slow process, but each Assembly election will slowly move away from that focus.
But all we can do is try to speak to as many voters as we can and do so with positive ideas about what we can change, not sending a message to London to a Government we cannot.
Gauntlet thrown down - positive vs negative.
Don't laugh too hard at the Lib Dems
I wrote this in response to this article.
It is interesting that everyone is so dismissive of the Lib Dems, yet their vote (if it does collapse/switch) will make or break many seats.
The whole ‘sell out’ schtick as been done to death. The Lib Dems would have been halving the deficit in a term with Labour, raising tuition fees on the Browne Review etc.
However, the total reversal of policy is only one part of the story, it is the total misunderstanding of what motivated their voters that will be the death of the Lib Dems. The Lib Dem growth was built on pitching at centre-left voters and just about holding together soft Tories who wouldn’t vote Labour, with an underpinning of tactical voting in most seats.
I genuinely believe that the Liberal Democrat do not have a USP in British politics. Liberals exist in all the other parties; UKIP, Tories, Labour, Plaid and Green. It is a neat but totally inept explanation to maintain the Lib Dems USP is ‘liberal vs authoritarian’.
Without the outsider, nice, tactical vote, you have the figure of ‘real’ liberal voters – that is all that is left from their poll figures.
So while we can all guffaw at the Lib Dems plight, I think we all might need to consider how much we look at our own parties. Understanding your vote and not assuming that they are all passionately for your policies is crucial with such a potential mobile electorate.
…and yes, in all the close seats in Wales, it could well be the collapse or switching of the Lib Dem vote than wins and loses those seats.
It is interesting that everyone is so dismissive of the Lib Dems, yet their vote (if it does collapse/switch) will make or break many seats.
The whole ‘sell out’ schtick as been done to death. The Lib Dems would have been halving the deficit in a term with Labour, raising tuition fees on the Browne Review etc.
However, the total reversal of policy is only one part of the story, it is the total misunderstanding of what motivated their voters that will be the death of the Lib Dems. The Lib Dem growth was built on pitching at centre-left voters and just about holding together soft Tories who wouldn’t vote Labour, with an underpinning of tactical voting in most seats.
I genuinely believe that the Liberal Democrat do not have a USP in British politics. Liberals exist in all the other parties; UKIP, Tories, Labour, Plaid and Green. It is a neat but totally inept explanation to maintain the Lib Dems USP is ‘liberal vs authoritarian’.
Without the outsider, nice, tactical vote, you have the figure of ‘real’ liberal voters – that is all that is left from their poll figures.
So while we can all guffaw at the Lib Dems plight, I think we all might need to consider how much we look at our own parties. Understanding your vote and not assuming that they are all passionately for your policies is crucial with such a potential mobile electorate.
…and yes, in all the close seats in Wales, it could well be the collapse or switching of the Lib Dem vote than wins and loses those seats.
Labels:
Plaid Cymru,
Welsh Assembly,
Welsh General Election
Saturday, 9 April 2011
The Social Mobility Myth
Social Mobility, who doesn't want more of it?
Well a fair number of people actually. Social mobility according to our politicians is a win-win. Stories of kids eating sawdust and bathing outdoors turning into high flying lawyers or some of those chinless successful business gurus we see.
That is only half the story.
I am generally someone who believes there is a finite amount of money and resources to go around. You can make gains or losses, there is always room for change, but generally it is about redistributing a finite cake.
The other half of the social mobility story is the one the ex-sawdust eater has replaced. This person would have been born into a wealthy family, got access to far more chances but had their place taken by the ex-sawdust eater.
Which is why we never actually see anything done by successive Westminster Governments. Ultimately social mobility will include alot of wealthy (nb. powerful) people's kids doing less well. While Britain remains one of the most unequal in Europe (after a decade or so of Labour Government no less), social mobility is a pipe dream and just the same hollow promise the last Government made.
From what I can see, social mobility is more prevalent in more equal societies. I would argue this because it makes moving up or down the ladder is not so extreme. The ex-sawdust eater would perhaps only go up a little bit to be deemed a move up, the rich kid vice versa downwards.
The fact is a society as unequal as Britian is never going to engender widespread social mobility. Life chances, a leg up and opportunity is hived off and guarded jealously by those that can access it. And lets be honest, given I have moved up the social mobility ladder, I am keen to give my kids everything they can to maintain that upwardly mobile curve. Some of the left demonise that, but I am a product of succeeding in spite of the system, don't demonise me for wanting my kids to succeed working with the current system.
I am all for increasing working class opportunity and positively doing something about it. One of the best ideas I heard was from Peter Wilby in the New Statesman - he argued that every single school, state and private should be given two places a year each to Oxford and Cambridge. The best two pupils in that year, from bog standard comp to Eton, would get the place.
Of course that is far to radical for the political class or even many non-working class people - it's far too fair and takes away their inbuilt advantages. And that my friends, is why social mobility is broken in the UK.
Well a fair number of people actually. Social mobility according to our politicians is a win-win. Stories of kids eating sawdust and bathing outdoors turning into high flying lawyers or some of those chinless successful business gurus we see.
That is only half the story.
I am generally someone who believes there is a finite amount of money and resources to go around. You can make gains or losses, there is always room for change, but generally it is about redistributing a finite cake.
The other half of the social mobility story is the one the ex-sawdust eater has replaced. This person would have been born into a wealthy family, got access to far more chances but had their place taken by the ex-sawdust eater.
Which is why we never actually see anything done by successive Westminster Governments. Ultimately social mobility will include alot of wealthy (nb. powerful) people's kids doing less well. While Britain remains one of the most unequal in Europe (after a decade or so of Labour Government no less), social mobility is a pipe dream and just the same hollow promise the last Government made.
From what I can see, social mobility is more prevalent in more equal societies. I would argue this because it makes moving up or down the ladder is not so extreme. The ex-sawdust eater would perhaps only go up a little bit to be deemed a move up, the rich kid vice versa downwards.
The fact is a society as unequal as Britian is never going to engender widespread social mobility. Life chances, a leg up and opportunity is hived off and guarded jealously by those that can access it. And lets be honest, given I have moved up the social mobility ladder, I am keen to give my kids everything they can to maintain that upwardly mobile curve. Some of the left demonise that, but I am a product of succeeding in spite of the system, don't demonise me for wanting my kids to succeed working with the current system.
I am all for increasing working class opportunity and positively doing something about it. One of the best ideas I heard was from Peter Wilby in the New Statesman - he argued that every single school, state and private should be given two places a year each to Oxford and Cambridge. The best two pupils in that year, from bog standard comp to Eton, would get the place.
Of course that is far to radical for the political class or even many non-working class people - it's far too fair and takes away their inbuilt advantages. And that my friends, is why social mobility is broken in the UK.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)